Most people use 3-second view rate as the first filter on TikTok openers, and it makes sense: if the first frame doesn't stop anyone, the hook is weak. But it's a cheap metric. Someone who scrolls past a bright opener still counts as a view, so an ad can look healthy at 3 seconds and then die at the offer.
I'd use 3-second views to judge the hook, and 6-second views, average watch time and CTR to judge the concept. Don't kill an ad until it has enough impressions for the gap to be real. Say a supplement brand tests two openers. A fast face close-up wins on 3-second views, but a slower product demo holds people longer and gets more clicks. In that case the demo is the better ad, even though it loses the first filter.
So which number do you use as the kill switch, and how much spend do you need before you trust it?